Thursday, August 28, 2008

BAD HABITS:A HISTORY OF HOARDING

An car a h' anns an t-seana mhaide is duilich a thoirt as. Straightening the bend in old wood is a difficult job.

"Mother Nature was giving us a clear message about the health of the river system, but it was not heeded," admitted local mayor Kym Hughes. [“Mayor: How we failed to heed the vital warning signs,” http://blogs.news.com.au/adelaidenow/guestblogger/index.php/adelaidenow/comments/kym_chugh/] McHugh organized a march of mourning across that Bridge on August 10th. About 5,000 people stopped in the middle for two minutes' silence to “underscore this 11th hour bid to save the nation's greatest river,” said McHugh. ["Crowds gather for rally at Murray River." http://www.thedaily.com.au/news/2008/aug/10/aap-crowds-gather-for-rally-at-murray-river] McHugh's confession must be a bitter pill for the Ngarrindjeri to swallow, for all along they have been making strong statements about the need to protect Ruwi. Ngarrindjeri women's sacred law/lore warned what would happen if the Hindmarsh Island Bridge cast its concrete shadow over Living Waters.

Perhaps the reason Mother Nature and the Ngarrindjeri grandmothers weren't listened to was because decision-makers have been stuck in a medieval mindset: dominion over rather than cooperation with Mother Nature.

The word “weir,” for example, has a warrior ethos. It was derived from the Old English werian, to defend and protect, says John Ayto. [Dictionary of Word Origins, p570] In Britain the first “serious” damming (damning?) of rivers was undertaken by medieval millers. The feudal laws of Norman invaders placed the mill-dam under the tight control of the manorial landowner. The term for such a dam is “impoundment” which has the clear meaning of taking water into formal custody. Medieval laws, such as thirlage, which reaped great profits for the landowner seem to have coupled inextricably economic wealth and water-hoarding. Before the Normans' brutal land grab, riparian water-sharing rights which held that a stream of running water could not be possessed were a feature of a land held in common. The Norman Conquest legitimized water-hoarding and entrenched water injustice in its society to the gain of a privileged few. Seems a habit hard to break.

Behaving badly over water began in Australia with colonization. It is a history of hoarding. The gap between water supply and water demand is as old as the province of South Australia. My red-haired Scottish forebear was a water-carter in 1840. (It's been like deja vu watching the water-trucks at Narrung this year.

"Disputes between the three colonies about the river started as soon as Victoria was declared separate from NSW in 1850," point out Daniel Connell. ["Federation? Managing the Water in the Murray-Darling Basin-a historic perspective." http://www.gardenhistorysociety.org.au/pdfs/Daniel%20Connell%20Paper%20AGHS%20Conf%20Oct%2007.pdf.]

In South Australia, the Rankines, a family of Scottish migrants, probably weren't the first to behave badly over water. But according to Jim Marsh, Barrage Superintendent at Goolwa. they wanted to “try and stop the ingress of sea water into that reach, to hold a pocket of fresh water for their stock for the summer.” So they were probably the first to build a Murray weir: a wooden weir across Mundoo Channel. Marsh didn't say when. Probably around the 1850s. No thought for the First Peoples, the Ngarrindjeri, for whom this area is particularly sacred. Stumps of the weir apparently still remain near the Mundoo Barrage. One of Marsh's stories blames dynamite for its demise. [Rose Geisler, Alexandrina Local History Archive. http://www.stateheritageareas.sa.gov.au/pdfs/stories_goolwa_marshjm.pdf.] Now, the Ngarrindjeri who traditionally used fire technology for environmental renewal, have yarns that hint at pyrotechnics to rid Ruwi of harmful structures.



In 1863, lobbying began to lock up the River Murray . When the river was a major highway, paddlesteamers road-trains, the "inland desert" a prize for land-grabbers, seasonal low flows impeded “progress.” More bad manners: NSW, Victoria and South Australia disputed ownership and failed to reach an agreement, . [“Lock and Weir No 1,” http://www.aussieheritage.com.au/listings/sa/Blanchetown/LockandWeirNo1/10733]

In 1880, upstream water “extractions” due to "desert" irrigation, together with drought, impacted severely on the lower lakes, write researchers Terry Sim and Kerri Muller. [“A Fresh History of the Lakes: Wellington to the Murray Mouth 1800s to 1935,” River Murray Catchment Water Management Board, 2004]

In the 1897/8 Australasian Federation Convention, more drought and depression meant management of the River Murray was debated with "fierceness." South Australia wanted its right to water enshrined in the national constitution. The other states wanted to protect their right to irrigate. Alfred Deakin suggested a formula for retaining state rights with the option for a federal authority. The latter was ignored, while one of the rare rights in the Australian Constitution. Section 100 states: “The Commonwealth shall not, by any law or regulation of trade or commerce, abridge the right of a State or of the residents therein to the reasonable use of the waters of rivers for conservation or irrigation.” [http://australianpolitics.com/constitution/text/100.shtml] In effect what the Australian Constitution enshrined was the right to squabble over water. The insistence of South Australia that the word "reasonable" be attached to "use of the waters" points to the fears it had about upstream behaviour. The legal battles continue to this day. ["High Court talks on Murray, Coorong." 15/08/2008. http://www.independentweekly.com.au/news/local/news/environment/high-court-talks-on-murray-coorong/1245685.aspx]

In 1902, upstream extractions lowered the lake to sea level, the water turned salty, water grasses rotted, reeking and contaminating both water and air, record Sim and Muller. Conditions were a “disaster,” said Mr F Garnet, Superintendent of the Point McLeay Mission, (Raukkan). He observed: “Despite the long drought, the waters of the lakes have always been sweet at this time of the year.” Wool-washing, the industry that supported the Ngarrindjeri community collapsed. Garnet lamented: “Its destruction means a loss of 200 pound per year to the natives.”

In 1902, a Federal Parliamentary Commission's enquiry into river levels recommended a proportional share of the river for the states in times of drought; the construction of storage works and weirs at the Murray mouth; and a complete system of locks. Vested interests used Section 100 of the Australian Constitution to thwart these measures.

In 1912, the SA Govt hired a Captain Johnson, Corps of Engineers, USA, to report on a scheme for “locking” the River Murray. The first lock was built at Blachetown in 1922.

In 1915, the River Murray Waters Agreement, designed to work with the Interstate Commission, a federal decision-making body, was signed between states. But the river agreement for management of the whole Murray-Darling Basin became a dud when a High Court challenge stripped the Commission of its powers, recounts Daniel Connell.

In 1935 a string of barrages began to be built near the Murray mouth to stop seawater flowing upstream for 250 kms. [“Effects of weirs, locks, barrages and dams,” http://www.slsa.sa.gov.au/murray/content/dwindlingRiver/wiersDamsIntro.htm] The barrages destroyed 90% of the estuarine environment. Power for the construction was provided by the paddle-steamer Capt Sturt. (My mum spent her school holidays on board. My granddad took snapshots. Deja vu again.) “Soon after the first locks were built,” the fishing forebears of Henry Jones observed that the freshwater crayfish began to decline. The species is now gone.

In 1967, drought stirred the SA govt to stop issuing Water Diversion Licences to irrigators. [Who Owns the Murray?ed Peter S. Davis & Phillip J Moore, pp 19, 48.] Professor of environmental law at Uni SA, Rob Fowler, has criticised licences as “a private property right” granted “over a public resource.” He asserted: “It was a market economy solution that just hasn’t worked.” [http://www.independentweekly.com.au/news/local/news/environment/high-court-talks-on-murray-coorong/1245685.aspx] Today, existing water licences are a complicated matter. The SA govt varies their conditions in order to control water allocation. Licences are divided into "a Water Access Entitlement, a Water Allocation, a Site Use Approval, a Water Resource Works Approval and a Delivery Capacity Entitlement." [http://www.dwlbc.sa.gov.au/licensing/swr/index.html] Each state has implemented different water allocating processes. In 1983, South Australia introduced water licence trading.

Due to reduced river flows, in 1981 the Murray mouth closed. The solution in 2002 was to dredge it open. It was supposed to be a $2m nine-month “Sand Pumping Project.” In 2005, Melissa Fyfe from The Age reported that dredging costs taxpayers $7m a year. [http://www.theage.com.au/news/National/More-help-to-keep-Murrays-mouth-open/2005/03/23/1111525218662.html.] Today dredging continues.

In 2008 the lower lakes reached record low levels. Here at Narrung, to prevent Lake Albert from collapse a $6m bund was built and pumping began at a cost of $600,000 a month. And recently, while the Federal govt announced a $50m pipeline for the Narrung Peninsula, the SA govt announced $30m for a weir at Wellington to secure Adelaide's drinking water.

Recent reports of upstream irrigators stealing water have emerged in the media. "Eight times the volume of Adelaide's drinking water" was being diverted from the Murray through unmetered pumps, claimed the SA Opposition Leader Martin Hamilton-Smith. ["Murray 'water theft' pumping angers SA Oppn." Aug 7, 2008. http://www.abc.net.au/news/stories/2008/08/07/2327092.htm?section=justin]. “60 cases of water theft “ are being investigated “in the Goulburn-Murray region of Victoria, Australia’s largest irrigation district, says researcher for the Water Integrity Network, Mark Worth. [“Crime and Drought in Australia’s Murray River Basin,” http://www.waterintegritynetwork.net/page/431]

Then, last week alleged illegal dams and irrigation channels on Qld's Paroo River, the healthiest tributary of the Murray-Darling, were condemned by SA's premier as “an act of terrorism against the nation.” [http://www.abc.net.au/news/stories/2008/08/15/2336850.htm?site=local] A moratorium on new dams and diversions had been put in place in 2001 by the Qld and NSW governments.

This week rural writer Asa Wahlquist reported that over the past years Queensland irrigators have been taking "record amounts of water from the Murray-Darling Basin," while "other state governments wound back irrigator allocations." ["Murray River drained by Queensland," August 21, 2008, http://www.theaustralian.news.com.au/story/0,25197,24215665-5013871,00.html] "This sort of behaviour, it is putting entire regions along the Murray-Darling Basin on their knees," said spokesperson for South Australian Murray Irrigators, Tim Whetstone. "At the moment, for the people who are up the top of the basin, it is first-in, best-dressed, showing no concern for anyone down lower. It is un-Australian."

Meanwhile, the river is losing its vital signs. The Murray Darling Commission states that public storages are holding 4,800 gigalitres of water: 21% of capacity. But the amount of water available to flow down the river can't be determined accurately, because of water diverted into the ownership of states and private landholders. This needs to be rectified urgently.

Cha bhi fios aire math an tobair gus an trĂ igh e. The value of the well is not known until it goes dry.

Wednesday, August 27, 2008

MAINTAINING A HEALTHY RIVER, BEGINS AT BIRTH

Namawi rawul-inyeri thulun-ar. Our footrpints come from the past. [Kungun Ngarrindjeri Miminar Yunnan, Listen to Ngarrindjeri Women Speaking,

Life lessons are written in Ngarrindjeri Ruwi. Here in waters now known as Loveday Bay, Spiritual Ancestor Nurunderi taught Creation-time fishers not to be greedy, but to share the Thukeri from the waters. At first the fishers took no notice, then they made excuses, and the consequences were dire. Nurunderi changed forever a favourite fish into a bony bream. For tens of thousands of years, the Ngarrindjeri have taught their children not to hoard. For thousands of years the river's waters flowed, Ruwi was healthy and people thrived. This region supported the densest population of First Peoples on the continent.

“You are one with the Earth and the Water. So you're connected through both: Mother Earth and our waters, because the waters are the lifeblood. They're the veins in our bodies in fact, and what's been happening is we've been damaging and blocking our arteries up by building all these locks and weirs and all sorts of other things which has made the system sick,” Matt Rigney, chair of MLDRIN, Murray Lower Darling Rivers Indigenous Nations, explained to SA's Stateline. [Leah MacLennan, “Coorong Drought,”30/05/2008 http://www.abc.net.au/stateline/sa/content/2006/s2262266.htm]

“I think people have to wake up and understand the difference between need and greed and I think there's been far too much greed has been overtaking common sense in regards to managing our waterways,” chided Ngarrindjeri Rupelli George Trevorrow. He warned: “It is an old saying, that once our totems go, we go. So it's a very big concern to us at the moment.”

The Ngarrindjeri are not alone in their concerns. The Murray Darling Basin is home for 75,000 First Peoples, most Traditional Owners. In 1998, as an initiative of the Yorta Yorta, First Peoples all along the river gathered to form MLDRIN (Murray Lower Darling Rivers Indigenous Nations). It's “an expression of the way the Indigenous Nations have always done business.” First Nations have been keeping the rivers healthy for thousands of years by “caring for country and talking to their traditional neighbours upstream and downstream on the Murray and its’ sister Rivers, Creeks, Lakes, Billabongs and waterways.” [MLDRIN - http://www.mldrin.org.au/about/stratplan.htm]

“The Indigenous vision for the river system is holistic – it incorporates spiritual, cultural, economic and social values. All are inter-related. All the issues need to be addressed together,” stated MLDRIN's Report to the Murray Darling Basin Commission in 2003. Thousands of years of respect for the river makes Traditional Owners “best placed to talk for Country,” but the decision-making has been dominated by immigrant, non-Indigenous “stake-holders.”

George Trevorrow pointed out to Stateline: “Every other group has been engaged, particularly irrigators and dairy farmers, rice growers, cotton growers. You name it, they've all been engaged. Aboriginal people have been a tack on. We don't want to be seen as a symbolic symbol or a gesture of symbolism. We want to be a part of the whole process and we want to engage in a proper way."

Ngarrindjeri knowledge of the river's bounty is ancient. In Ngarrindjeri accounts of Creation, Nurunderi chased a great fish Pondi down a little stream and the fish's frantic movements carved a great waterway down to the lakes. There Pondi was cut up, filling the lakes with a diversity of fish. The food supply supported an abundance that amazed Captain Sturt in 1830. From the cliffs at a bend in the river, now known as Tailem Bend, three thousand warriors watched and readied as Sturt's crew rowed downstream. Despite breaking traditional Law of entering Country, Sturt was allowed to pass by circumspect elders.

According to oral history, Ngarrindjeri old people welcomed the British foreigners to Country in their usual way, asking them to look after it. But the foreign Occupiers disrespect for the River over the past two centuries has broken the law of Caring for Country.

“Does anyone have a solution?”

A government minister or two and invited stakeholders had met to discuss the water crisis for the Lower Lakes and Kurangk, my Ngarrindjeri raconteur explained. Giving me a prime-time re-play of proceedings, he shot up his hand and said eagerly:

“I do. All you convicts and hangers-on go home. Then there'd be plenty of water for us blackfellas.”

Those assembled laughed, said my friend, but I could read something very serious in his face. And I realized that Steve Walker, the Chair of Raukkan Community, had said in a few words what it has taken me weeks to write in over 6000!

The Ngarrindjeri spoke up all the way to the High Court but few listened. The River's slow creeping death is now strangling businesses. Fair cop for us. We are not helpless. We can can change from water hoarders to healers. We as a community have to be prepared to pay the repair bill. But not warranted is the cruelty inflicted upon the turtles, the fish, the wading birds, the Australian otters, the water grasses and the mussels which strew the lake-edge in their thousands, their last gasp for life immortalized in the now toxic mud.

An intimately connected web of Nature, the once wealthy delta of the River Murray, is so torn it will be soon impossible to repair.

WATER-WISE?


In the 1960's I went to school in Ralph Jacobi's electorate: bless his river-loving soul. Every classroom had a water-wise poster. We were drilled that we lived “in the driest state of the driest continent.” (Unpopulated Antarctica didn't count.) We were taught how we relied on the River Murray for our water supply. SA Water says that these days, the River Murray supplies in an average year "about 40% of the State’s urban water needs." In drought, it supplies "as much as 90%." [Pipelines, SA Water, http://www.sawater.com.au/SAWater/Education/OurWaterSystems/Pipelines.htm]

With our recent record drought, there's record low flows coming down the River. Big big problem for us here on the Narrung Peninsula! But, I reckon the solution lies in the obvious: Water.

In Australia, areas with higher average incomes use more water. This is true too for the world. The average Gambian uses only 4.5 litres per day, while an Australian uses 930. When may forebear was carting water, South Australians made do with no more than16 litres a day, estimates Maureen M Leadbeater. ["Water: South Australia's Early Days." http://www.adelaideco-op.familyhistorysa.info/water.html]And while the global annual average rainfall is 746mm, the average rainfall in Australia is 469mm, South Australia 236mm. [http://www.savewater.com.au/index.php?sectionid=42]

Every living cell needs water to live. 75% of a living tree is water. 75% of the human brain is water. Of the more than 15 million chemical species presently known, water is unique and far more complex than the formula H20 suggests. Water has a great ability to attract atoms from other substances, due to the electrical charges on its molecules. This enables water to act as a solvent in the body. The purer it is, the more essential nutrients, like magnesium, calcium, iodine, selenium and zinc, it can carry to the cells; or the more toxins, including mercury, lead and cadmium, it can carry away. Water plays the same role in the body we call the Earth. 71% of the planet's surface is covered by water, mostly too salty to drink. About 3% is fresh enough to drink. 1 billion people lack enough safe, clean drinking water. Water is so valuable that the United Nations Conference on the Human Environment declared that it must be "safeguarded for the benefit of present and future generations through careful planning or management, as appropriate." Principle 2, 16 June 1972, Stockholm.



Healthy water flows. Hoarded water suffers and sickens. It accrues pathogens and pollutants. "Water quality," observes Juergen Scmidt, "is directly affected by the flow of co-operative energies circulating between people, animals, insects, and plants through out the ecosystem." . [The Hidden Forces of Nature, p38.]



Back in 2005, Austalian scientists demonstrated that people massacring trees reduces rainfall. Apparently, one in every 500 water molecules has its second hydrogen atom swapped for a heavier deuterium version. The heavier water molecules are slower to evaporate from rivers and groundwater, but the leaves of plants and trees, through transpiration, give them off more readily. Less trees: less rain! It's another reason to protect Australia's forests. [Richard Macey, "Fewer trees, less rain: study uncovers deforestation equation," http://www.smh.com.au/news/Environment/Fewer-trees-less-rain-the-deforestation-equation/2005/03/03/1109700611592.html]

The Narrung Peninsula knows all too well the problems deforestation causes to hydrology. It lies in the Coorong District Council where only 19% of native vegetation remains. Dryland salinity has affected 50,000 ha with a further 70,000 at risk. 12,000 ha are irrigated. ["Coorong District Council," http://www.environment.gov.au/biodiversity/publications/incentives-forum/pubs/day3/coorong-paper.pdf] Wide-scale reforestation is not a simple solution. Trees need water to get established. Plantation water-use varies greatly, show CSIRO studies in South Australia.[CSIRO, "Measuring the water use of plantation trees" http://www.csiro.au/science/MeasuringPlantationWaterUse.html]
Water, or lack of it, isn't our region's problem. It is our behaviour!

It's time decision-makers stop behaving like feudal dukes guarding their own interests. For a healthy river, Country needs sociable behaviour. The Save The River Murray Levy, added to every one's SA Water bill since 2003, is an example of sociable behaviour towards our precious source of water. Rubbing shoulders at recent water meetings and rallies around the Lower Lakes were government boffins, irrigators, yachties, greenies, First Peoples and polies. People you just don't expect to see together are coming together, all for the need of water.

So, who stands out as the wisest when it comes to the River Murray? Who are the healers and who are the hoarders?

Eisd ri gaoth nam beann gus an traoigh na h-uisgeachan. Listen to the mountain wind, till the streams abate. [Gaelic seanfhocail, old words: proverb]

“PROBLEMS CREATE SOLUTIONS”



It was sunset. Ngarrindjeri Ruwi, lands and waters, lay before us. The sky turned from blue to mauve to indigo, and then under moonlight, the vast body of water now known as Lake Alexandrina, began to shine. Lights sparkled from Raukkan, ancient Ngarrindjeri homelands. My companion, an elder, was silent. We nursed a shared grief. With serenity above and below us, it was hard to credit that the lake and its inhabitants were stressed, almost to the point of exhaustion. But the uncharacteristic thin snake of a sandbar way off in the middle of the lake was a sign that something is wrong, so very wrong.

“The problem creates the solution.” Did Confucius say that? Or Dr Who? Whoever. The River Murray certainly has plenty of problems:

Over-allocation that has reduced the River Murray's flow by over three-quarters.
Drought.
Century's old squabbling between states.
Upstream "hoarders."
Downstream "whingers."
Water thieves.
Water gluttons.
Marginalized Traditional Owners.

Endangered sources of traditional food and medicine.
6 million trees felled in the Murray-Darling Basin.
Barrages. Locks. Weirs.
Evaporation.
Inappropriate European farming and crops.

Rising salinity levels.
Pesticides, herbicides that kill soil bacteria, rob the soil of moisture, and mobilize salinity.
Destruction of the natural water-cleansing biodiversity.
Species extinctions.
Inappropriate introduced species.
Impediments to fish passage along the rive
Disregard of the Ramsar Treaty to protect the habitat of migratory birds.
Unusable, undrinkable water, polluted by heavy metals, salt, pathogens, algal blooms.
Exposed toxic soils: sulphur acidification.

Stressed landholders and traders.
Shrinking profits, bankrupt businesses, shrinking communities..
Disoriented, depressed and dislocated families.
Resentment of "environmental" flows.
Increased groundwater use.
Danger of bushfire.

Climate change.
Reforestation altering patterns of run-off.
Reduced return flows from irrigation.
Australia's food bowl concentrated in the Murray Darling Basin.
And as Ngarrindjeri elder Matt Rigney pointed out: Population growth from two centuries of post-Invasion immigration....

If it's true that problems create solutions, then Australia's current water crisis will generate solutions of galactic proportions, given the hordes of challenges.


Friday, June 20, 2008

Rights and Responsibilites



"Indigenous peoples have the right to the conservation and protection of the environment and the productive capacity of their lands or territories and resources. States shall establish and implement assistance programmes for indigenous peoples for such conservation and protection, without discrimination."Article 29 of the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, adopted 13 September 2007

Raukkan Ngarrindjeri Community jetty 2000



Raukkan jetty 2008




"The natural resources of the earth, including the air, water, land, flora and fauna and especially representative samples of natural ecosystems, must be safeguarded for the benefit of present and future generations through careful planning or management, as appropriate." Principle 2, 16 June 1972, Stockholm, Declaration of the United Nations Conference on the Human Environment

Narrung wetland 15th June, 2006



Narrung dryland, 27th June, 2008



"The discharge of toxic substances or of other substances ... in such quantities or concentrations as to exceed the capacity of the environment to render them harmless, must be halted in order to ensure that serious or irreversible damage is not inflicted upon ecosystems. ... "Principle 6


“Oxidation of acid sulfate soils potentially releases acid (measured by pH), changes alkalinity(measure of the ability of water to buffer acid conditions) amnd releases iron and sulphate. The (Lake Albert Water Level Management) project could potentially have caused acid and associated contaminants to be mobilised due to flushing of the Narrung narrows or increasing the water level in Lake Albert.

"The pumping of water into Lake Albert potentially could also have increased turbidity (through sediment disturbance) and'or altered salinity in lake Albert.

"At present there has been no apparent change in the overall water quality of Lake Albert...Alkalinity and pH level are currently maintained at satisfactory levels in both the Lakes...

"The water level is being maintained above the critical level of -0.6m AHD which prevents large scale exposure of acid sulfate soils and potential acidification of the Lake.

“The Coorong District Council Water issues Update #3, June 2008"

The Importance of Freshwater Flows:

According to the Ngarrindjeri nation Yarluwar-Ruwe, Caring for Ngarrindjeri Sea, Country and Culture, freshwater fishing has been "fundamental" to Ngarrindjeri "cultural economy since time immemorial." The Ngarrindjeri knowledge of "marine, intertidal, estuarine and freshwater environments" has enabled the nation to "sustainably harvest many species of fish and shellfish." These species are not considered commodities, but many are Ngarrrindjeri ngartji , "totems or special friends," and are significant in Ngarrindjeri "creation stories and have other cultural values." ...




Wednesday, June 18, 2008

A flood of headlines



“SA natural icons dying from thirst,” The Independent Weekly
“Govt in damage control over Murray-Darling report,” The World Today, ABC news
“SA alone can't save lower Murray, Coorong: minister,” Yahoo news
“ACF urges emergency action for Murray Lower Lakes and the Coorong,” prismwebcastnews
“SA urged to lead Murray revival,” ABC news
“Murray-Darling Basin is dying: report,” Ninemsn news
“Murray lakes may be lost,” The Age
“Murray on verge of last gasp,” Sydney Morning Herald
“Murray-Darling raindance,” Blogocracy blog

The only floods around here lately are headlines. What the lakes and Coorong need is water.

The Lower Lakes are at the lowest ebb in recorded history:

"In May this year Lake Alexandrina water levels were as low as 0.69 metres below sea level. Lake Albert was as low as 0.74 metres below sea level, placing it in danger of ecological disaster."( Dr Simon Benger, researcher, Flinders University School of Geography, Population and Environmental Management.

"In 2002 it was estimated that median freshwater flows at the Murray Mouth had been reduced to 27% of natural flows... No water releases through the barrages have occurred since October 2006 but saline intrusion has occurred back into the Lakes as a result of the level of the seawater on the downstream side of the barrages being higher than the lake level...The lakes are now at "(- 0.5m AHD), about 1.2m below their normal pool level. Based on geological evidence the Lakes have never been below sea level in the 7 500 years since they formed." Substantial amounts of fresh water are needed in the lakes by October if irreparable ecological collapse is to be avoided. (Lakes Alexandrina And Albert Ecological Condition Progress Report. SA Murray-Darling Basin Natural Resource Management Board, April 2008)

Highly reactive acid sulphate soils

Over 3 000 ha of sediment on lake fringes and wetlands has been exposed to the air. (NRM Porgress Report) There is real danger of forming "sulphuric acid which can then leach into the soil, wetlands and the lake itself killing organisms and ecosystems." (Dr Simon Benger)

There is a likelihood that the water and sediment chemistry can "release a range of heavy metals and toxic metalloids into the water body at concentrations hazardous to human health, water ecology, livestock, flora and fauna...CSIRO data shows that over 1 000 ha of the dried lake margins is currently sulfuric (pH<4).>

High salinity levels

"Salinity levels currently stand at 4258 EC (electrical conductivity) units in Lake Alexandrina and 4168 in Lake Albert, or approximately four times accepted maximum levels for Adelaide drinking water."(Dr Simon Benger) This is Raukkan and Narrung's water supply.

Contaminated ground water

"There is some evidence of local shallow groundwater becoming acidic." (NRM Porgress Report)

Dredging at the Murray Mouth

"Some $2 million per year" has been spent since 2002 on dredging sediments at the Murray Mouth, once scoured clear by Murray River flows. This "is the only thing keeping many species alive within the Coorong as tidal seawater flows in and out of the Mouth. " (Dr Simon Benger)

Damaged Ngarrindjeri burial grounds

Falling water levels have exposed Ngarrindjeri burial grounds. The Ngarrinjderi community is distressed by damage and looting.

"Cattle have been walking through them, people have been picking up skulls and bones and taking them home as trophies..."observed Ngarrindjeri elder Matt Rigney.

Dying vegetation

"Large stands of water milfoil (Myriophyllum sp.) situated to the north of Hindmarsh Island have died as a result of increased salinities in this region. This species provides valuable habitat for small bodied native fish, and a food source for birds such as swans. ...If freshwater returns to the Lakes then wetland plants, which are good
seed dispersers, may return providing sediment conditions are favourable"(NRM Porgress Report)

Endangered fish

"There is potential under the ‘no improvement’ scenario that water quality conditions will deteriorate sufficiently (elevated salinity levels, decreasing pH, heavy metals being mobilised together with elevated temperatures in summer reducing dissolved oxygen) that a major fish kill in the Lakes could result."(NRM Porgress Report)

A captive breeding program is rescuing "endangered native fish found in the lower lakes of the Murray in South Australia." (Mike Hammer, of Native Fish Australia)

Endangered frogs

"The lack of water and habitat has greatly reduced frog populations." (NRM Progress Report)

Endangered birds

"Waterbird numbers for most species declined in 2005, 2006 and 2007. (David Paton, 2008) Australia has an obligation under the Ramsar treaty to protect the habitat of migratory wading birds.

Endangered mussels

"The freshwater mussel is washing up dead on the shores of Lake Albert in large numbers." This occurrence is likely to spread to Lake Alexandrina. (NRM Porgress Report)

Endangered invertebrates

"These species show a reduction in diversity and abundance when salinities exceed 2 500 EC and significant impacts may occur if lake salinities exceed 5 000 EC." Invertebrates are a major food source for fish and birds. (NRM Porgress Report)

Invasion by marine polychaete worms

"Larger creatures such as crabs and turtles are being overwhelmed by the weight of worm formations on their shells and are dying in large numbers. Such effects are thought to be due to rising salinity levels throughout the Lower Lakes." (Dr Simon Benger)

Increased likelihood of algae blooms

"Physical conditions in the river and the Lakes (low flows, temperature stratification, low turbidity) are conducive to algal bloom formation." (NRM Porgress Report)

Low dissolved oxygen


"Temperature and salinity stratification due to low flows could result in depletion of
dissolved oxygen in the bottom waters and deeper pools of the river.... could result in large amount of phosphorus being released from the sediments and this may trigger algal blooms... Persistent low dissolved oxygen (less than 5mg/l) levels would impact on fish growth and further reduction (less than 1 mg/L) would result in fish kills." (NRM Porgress Report)

Urgently needed water flows

In excess of 600 GL of water is needed to raise lake levels to +0.3m AHD to improve the "health of the Lakes ecosystems... This would still not be sufficient to achieve reconnection with the Coorong, which would occur at around +0.65m AHD and require approximately 800 GL. Once Lake levels reach +0.65 m AHD, all fishways are operational. Regular flushing and fishway operation would begin to restore connectivity between the
Mouth, Coorong and Lakes enabling fish to migrate and complete their life cycles." (NRM Progress Report)

Artificial life support for the disconnected lakes

In May 470 ML were pumped from Lake Alexandrina to Lake Albert each day. In June it's expected 360 will be pumped, dropping in August to 200Ml and pumping stops at the end of September when funding ceases. The pumps are currently run on bio-diesel with pumping costing $600,000 a month.

"After this time, a greater volume (up to 1 GL per day) will be needed to prevent the lake level from dropping or other options will need to be considered...The decline in ecological character can only be halted and reversed if substantial freshwater inflows are received within the next six months." (NRM Progress Report)

Limited management options

"...we don't have the water in this state to be able to fix these problems; it must be dealt with at a national level," said SA Water Security Minister Karlene Maywald.

"Management options for the lower lakes are limited," Environment Minister Peter Garrett told Parliament, after the fourth-driest autumn on record had left "storages in the lower Murray-Darling ... at record lows.

So without significant flows into Lake Alexandrina, what will happen to Lake Albert at the end of September when funding for the emergency pumping of water stops?

Seawater pumping into Lake Albert?
"This would only be considered as a last resort if Lake Albert was definitely going to
become acidic... flooding Lake Albert with seawater would also lead to permanent ecological change:-

"Loss of freshwater species and food chain impacts.
"Salt intolerant and emergent vegetation species would be degraded and depleted contributing to the nutrient load.
"If seawater was put into Lake Albert and there was no connection to Lake Alexandrina, then a large fish kill would most likely occur.
"After 12 months it would change to a totally marine system. "(NRM Progress Report)