Friday, June 20, 2008

Rights and Responsibilites



"Indigenous peoples have the right to the conservation and protection of the environment and the productive capacity of their lands or territories and resources. States shall establish and implement assistance programmes for indigenous peoples for such conservation and protection, without discrimination."Article 29 of the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, adopted 13 September 2007

Raukkan Ngarrindjeri Community jetty 2000



Raukkan jetty 2008




"The natural resources of the earth, including the air, water, land, flora and fauna and especially representative samples of natural ecosystems, must be safeguarded for the benefit of present and future generations through careful planning or management, as appropriate." Principle 2, 16 June 1972, Stockholm, Declaration of the United Nations Conference on the Human Environment

Narrung wetland 15th June, 2006



Narrung dryland, 27th June, 2008



"The discharge of toxic substances or of other substances ... in such quantities or concentrations as to exceed the capacity of the environment to render them harmless, must be halted in order to ensure that serious or irreversible damage is not inflicted upon ecosystems. ... "Principle 6


“Oxidation of acid sulfate soils potentially releases acid (measured by pH), changes alkalinity(measure of the ability of water to buffer acid conditions) amnd releases iron and sulphate. The (Lake Albert Water Level Management) project could potentially have caused acid and associated contaminants to be mobilised due to flushing of the Narrung narrows or increasing the water level in Lake Albert.

"The pumping of water into Lake Albert potentially could also have increased turbidity (through sediment disturbance) and'or altered salinity in lake Albert.

"At present there has been no apparent change in the overall water quality of Lake Albert...Alkalinity and pH level are currently maintained at satisfactory levels in both the Lakes...

"The water level is being maintained above the critical level of -0.6m AHD which prevents large scale exposure of acid sulfate soils and potential acidification of the Lake.

“The Coorong District Council Water issues Update #3, June 2008"

The Importance of Freshwater Flows:

According to the Ngarrindjeri nation Yarluwar-Ruwe, Caring for Ngarrindjeri Sea, Country and Culture, freshwater fishing has been "fundamental" to Ngarrindjeri "cultural economy since time immemorial." The Ngarrindjeri knowledge of "marine, intertidal, estuarine and freshwater environments" has enabled the nation to "sustainably harvest many species of fish and shellfish." These species are not considered commodities, but many are Ngarrrindjeri ngartji , "totems or special friends," and are significant in Ngarrindjeri "creation stories and have other cultural values." ...




Wednesday, June 18, 2008

A flood of headlines



SA natural icons dying from thirst,” The Independent Weekly
Govt in damage control over Murray-Darling report,” The World Today, ABC news
SA alone can't save lower Murray, Coorong: minister,” Yahoo news
ACF urges emergency action for Murray Lower Lakes and the Coorong,” prismwebcastnews
SA urged to lead Murray revival,” ABC news
Murray-Darling Basin is dying: report,” Ninemsn news
Murray lakes may be lost,” The Age
Murray on verge of last gasp,” Sydney Morning Herald
Murray-Darling raindance,” Blogocracy blog

The only floods around here lately are headlines. What the lakes and Coorong need is water.

The Lower Lakes are at the lowest ebb in recorded history:

"In May this year Lake Alexandrina water levels were as low as 0.69 metres below sea level. Lake Albert was as low as 0.74 metres below sea level, placing it in danger of ecological disaster."( Dr Simon Benger, researcher, Flinders University School of Geography, Population and Environmental Management.

"In 2002 it was estimated that median freshwater flows at the Murray Mouth had been reduced to 27% of natural flows... No water releases through the barrages have occurred since October 2006 but saline intrusion has occurred back into the Lakes as a result of the level of the seawater on the downstream side of the barrages being higher than the lake level...The lakes are now at "(- 0.5m AHD), about 1.2m below their normal pool level. Based on geological evidence the Lakes have never been below sea level in the 7 500 years since they formed." Substantial amounts of fresh water are needed in the lakes by October if irreparable ecological collapse is to be avoided. (Lakes Alexandrina And Albert Ecological Condition Progress Report. SA Murray-Darling Basin Natural Resource Management Board, April 2008)

Highly reactive acid sulphate soils

Over 3 000 ha of sediment on lake fringes and wetlands has been exposed to the air. (NRM Porgress Report) There is real danger of forming "sulphuric acid which can then leach into the soil, wetlands and the lake itself killing organisms and ecosystems." (Dr Simon Benger)

There is a likelihood that the water and sediment chemistry can "release a range of heavy metals and toxic metalloids into the water body at concentrations hazardous to human health, water ecology, livestock, flora and fauna...CSIRO data shows that over 1 000 ha of the dried lake margins is currently sulfuric (pH<4).>

High salinity levels

"Salinity levels currently stand at 4258 EC (electrical conductivity) units in Lake Alexandrina and 4168 in Lake Albert, or approximately four times accepted maximum levels for Adelaide drinking water."(Dr Simon Benger) This is Raukkan and Narrung's water supply.

Contaminated ground water

"There is some evidence of local shallow groundwater becoming acidic." (NRM Porgress Report)

Dredging at the Murray Mouth

"Some $2 million per year" has been spent since 2002 on dredging sediments at the Murray Mouth, once scoured clear by Murray River flows. This "is the only thing keeping many species alive within the Coorong as tidal seawater flows in and out of the Mouth. " (Dr Simon Benger)

Damaged Ngarrindjeri burial grounds

Falling water levels have exposed Ngarrindjeri burial grounds. The Ngarrinjderi community is distressed by damage and looting.

"Cattle have been walking through them, people have been picking up skulls and bones and taking them home as trophies..."observed Ngarrindjeri elder Matt Rigney.

Dying vegetation

"Large stands of water milfoil (Myriophyllum sp.) situated to the north of Hindmarsh Island have died as a result of increased salinities in this region. This species provides valuable habitat for small bodied native fish, and a food source for birds such as swans. ...If freshwater returns to the Lakes then wetland plants, which are good
seed dispersers, may return providing sediment conditions are favourable"(NRM Porgress Report)

Endangered fish

"There is potential under the ‘no improvement’ scenario that water quality conditions will deteriorate sufficiently (elevated salinity levels, decreasing pH, heavy metals being mobilised together with elevated temperatures in summer reducing dissolved oxygen) that a major fish kill in the Lakes could result."(NRM Porgress Report)

A captive breeding program is rescuing "endangered native fish found in the lower lakes of the Murray in South Australia." (Mike Hammer, of Native Fish Australia)

Endangered frogs

"The lack of water and habitat has greatly reduced frog populations." (NRM Progress Report)

Endangered birds

"Waterbird numbers for most species declined in 2005, 2006 and 2007. (David Paton, 2008) Australia has an obligation under the Ramsar treaty to protect the habitat of migratory wading birds.

Endangered mussels

"The freshwater mussel is washing up dead on the shores of Lake Albert in large numbers." This occurrence is likely to spread to Lake Alexandrina. (NRM Porgress Report)

Endangered invertebrates

"These species show a reduction in diversity and abundance when salinities exceed 2 500 EC and significant impacts may occur if lake salinities exceed 5 000 EC." Invertebrates are a major food source for fish and birds. (NRM Porgress Report)

Invasion by marine polychaete worms

"Larger creatures such as crabs and turtles are being overwhelmed by the weight of worm formations on their shells and are dying in large numbers. Such effects are thought to be due to rising salinity levels throughout the Lower Lakes." (Dr Simon Benger)

Increased likelihood of algae blooms

"Physical conditions in the river and the Lakes (low flows, temperature stratification, low turbidity) are conducive to algal bloom formation." (NRM Porgress Report)

Low dissolved oxygen


"Temperature and salinity stratification due to low flows could result in depletion of
dissolved oxygen in the bottom waters and deeper pools of the river.... could result in large amount of phosphorus being released from the sediments and this may trigger algal blooms... Persistent low dissolved oxygen (less than 5mg/l) levels would impact on fish growth and further reduction (less than 1 mg/L) would result in fish kills." (NRM Porgress Report)

Urgently needed water flows

In excess of 600 GL of water is needed to raise lake levels to +0.3m AHD to improve the "health of the Lakes ecosystems... This would still not be sufficient to achieve reconnection with the Coorong, which would occur at around +0.65m AHD and require approximately 800 GL. Once Lake levels reach +0.65 m AHD, all fishways are operational. Regular flushing and fishway operation would begin to restore connectivity between the
Mouth, Coorong and Lakes enabling fish to migrate and complete their life cycles." (NRM Progress Report)

Artificial life support for the disconnected lakes

In May 470 ML were pumped from Lake Alexandrina to Lake Albert each day. In June it's expected 360 will be pumped, dropping in August to 200Ml and pumping stops at the end of September when funding ceases. The pumps are currently run on bio-diesel with pumping costing $600,000 a month.

"After this time, a greater volume (up to 1 GL per day) will be needed to prevent the lake level from dropping or other options will need to be considered...The decline in ecological character can only be halted and reversed if substantial freshwater inflows are received within the next six months." (NRM Progress Report)

Limited management options

"...we don't have the water in this state to be able to fix these problems; it must be dealt with at a national level," said SA Water Security Minister Karlene Maywald.

"Management options for the lower lakes are limited," Environment Minister Peter Garrett told Parliament, after the fourth-driest autumn on record had left "storages in the lower Murray-Darling ... at record lows.

So without significant flows into Lake Alexandrina, what will happen to Lake Albert at the end of September when funding for the emergency pumping of water stops?

Seawater pumping into Lake Albert?
"This would only be considered as a last resort if Lake Albert was definitely going to
become acidic... flooding Lake Albert with seawater would also lead to permanent ecological change:-

"Loss of freshwater species and food chain impacts.
"Salt intolerant and emergent vegetation species would be degraded and depleted contributing to the nutrient load.
"If seawater was put into Lake Albert and there was no connection to Lake Alexandrina, then a large fish kill would most likely occur.
"After 12 months it would change to a totally marine system. "(NRM Progress Report)

Thursday, June 5, 2008

All is connected

Stitch by Stitch,
Circle by Circle,

Weaving is like the creation of life,

all things are connected.

[Ngarrindjeri weaver, Ellen Trevorrow, 2005, quoted in Caring for Ngarrindjeri Sea Country and Culture, p51]




For thousands of years, the Ngarrindjeri in daily greetings, in the retelling of Creation Stories, in pakari prayers songs, in ngrilkulun dancing and ringballin singing ceremonies, in charging objects with the sacred, have observed the cycle of life and maintained connection with Country.



The Ngarrindjeri say: Our lands, Our Waters, Our People, All Living things are connected.



We implore people to respect our Ruwe (Country) as it was created in the Kaldowinyeri ( the Creation).


We long for the sparkling clean waters, healthy land and people and all living things.



We long for the Yarluwar-Ruwe (Sea Country) of our ancestors.



Our vision is all people Caring, Sharing, Knowing and Respecting the lands, waters and all living things."
[Caring for Ngarrindjeri Sea Sea Country and Culture, p5]



All is connected.



Land sustains language.



Language sustains the land.



The words of First Peoples, shaped by intimate knowledge of of the terrain, waters, turning of tides, stars, seasons, sing out to Country in ways that are life affirming for all.



Language has an ecological link with homelands.



Language diversity is connected explicitly with the health of the environment, assert anthropologist Daniel Nettle and professor of English Suzanne Romain, in Vanishing Voices: The Extinction of the World's Languages, 2000.



The oral tradition of the Ngarrindjeri holds the origins of their language-groups. Ngarrindjeri language diversity was created from a feast upon Wururi, Grandmother Spider. Connected by silken threads, the hatchlings of the huntsman spider feed on pre-digested food from their mother's mouth, points out anthropologist Diane Bell. [Bell, Ngarrindjeri Wurruwarrin, p137]



For thousands of years, the Ngarrindjeri have gathered on the island where their heritage of language originated: Kumarangk. But when the Hindmarsh Island Bridge was opened on March 4th 2000, culturally appropriate access to Kumarangk (Hindmarsh Island) via the ferry was removed.



The impact of this on the Ngarrindjeri community has been cruel. Community Health Worker, Andrea Henschke observed:

"When the bridge was built, the women were diempowered and dispossesed all over again. The impact on their psyche was dramatic and physical health issues have been exacerbated. Diabetes and heart disease are significant issues for older Ngarrindjeri women. Substance abuse and suicide are issues for the young. Violence and abuse against women within the community is of great concern." [V Tjukonai, "The Language of the land" in Women and Sustainability, Woman's Studies Journal, York University, 2002]

"Emotionally it was very traumatic," said Ngarrindjeri elder Veronica Brodie. "We Ngarrindjeri women have had to try and get through the hard times we've had ...There is a great need for love and forgiveness all round." [Veronica Brodie, My Side of the Bridge, pp160,162]

For Country to regenerate, for the lands and waters to be healthy, they need the prayers, songs, stories: nurturing relationship with the Ngarrindjeri. And "the land and waters must be healthy for the Ngarrindjeri people to be healthy," said Tom Trevorrow. All is connected.

The mouth, lakes and Coorong that are the lungs of the River are dying, and without them, the River dies. Now that Lake Albert at the lower end of the River Murray is on artificial life support to prevent it from irretrievable collapse, respect for Country is desperately needed.



COUNTRY:
But the English words used to relate to Country are stuck in medieval European concepts of dominion over the land. In 1066, a Norman duke made himself king and sole owner of England, William the Conqueror's word for "country" was the Old French cuntree, an abbreviation of the medieval Latin terra contrata, "land opposite or before one." [John Ayto, Dictionary of Word Origins, p140] Up until the 15th century, "country" meant a "foreign land;" land to be invaded, dominated and plundered.



This medieval concept of dominion over "country" was transported to this continent, along with the convict labour to achieve that dominion. Today, Australians generally use a possessively article when referring to Country. It's usually "my" or "our country."

"The Creator who gave us life taught us not to fight over Country, but to share," said Ngarrindjeri elder Dorothy Shaw.



The meaning of English words change, because they are not rooted in the soil of their homeland. English linguists talk about English words being "acquired," "introduced" or "borrowed," when in actuality they were imposed from the language of the Conqueror or stolen from the tongues of the conquered in a long and bloody history of Empire-building. Below is a list of English words which came into being care of the Norman Conquest, and almost a millennium later, still maintain a discourse of feudal dominance over the land.

ARMY: "Army," "war" and "range" all have Old French origins, thanks to the Norman Invasion. "Range" originally meant a row or line of soldiers or hunters.

CATTLE:
"Cattle" and "chattel," are the same word etymologically, points out John Ayto.
[Dictionary of Word Origins, p102] Both imply ownership via the Old French chatel from the medieval Latin capitale "property," source of the English "capital."

COURT: In the twelfth century, "court," was the royal household and its retinue. It was derived from the Old French curt, from the Latin cortem, from cohors enclosed yard, but extended to mean those who assembled in such a yard: "a crowd of attendants" or a "company of soldier," says Ayto. "Court" became an assembly of judges, likely influenced by the Latin curia "sovereign's assembly" and "legal tribunal," because Norman "assemblies for justice" were " overseen by the sovereign personally," says Douglas Harper. COURTEOUS: from the Old French curties, in the thirteenth century meant "having courtly bearing or manners," and denoted an educated man, says Harper.



CIVIL and CIVILIZE: In the Norman imposed feudal society, superiors, the Norman nobles, were "courteous," while inferiors, the English who were given no recourse to education, were "civil," says Harper, via Old French from the Latin civilis "of citizens." French gave English "civilize," meaning "citified"
in the 17th century, and "civilization" in the 18th century, referring originally to a legal process of making a criminal "civil," but it came to mean the opposite of "barbarity."

The colonizing British in Australia justified genocide by regarding the continent's First Peoples as a sub-human barbaric race who needed to be "Christianized" and civilized:
"The aborigines of South Australia ...if compared with mankind in general or with barbarous nations alone: they rank the very lowest, and are almost without exception the most inferior; whether in a moral -- intellectual (mental), or civilized point of view." [amateur ethnographer, William Cawthorne, quoted in Survival in Our Own Land, p4]



DANGER:
"Danger" and "dominion" both derive ultimately, says Ayto, from the Vulgar latin domniarium "power of a lord." This led to the Old French dangier and the Anglo-Norman daunger. To be in someone's "danger," meant to be in the power or at the mercy of a lord or master who could punish, which led to the evolution of danger's meaning of peril.



DESMESNE/DOMAIN
Under the feudal system
imposed in the 12th century by William the Bastard, "desmesne," from the Old French "demeine," was land retained by a lord for his own private use and not let out to tenants. It is now a legal term for the possession of real estate. "Domain" arrived in English in the 17th century via Scots but from the same French source as "desmesne." The Domain in Sydney, the Queen's Domain in Hobart, the Domain Parklands in Melbourne refer to land that was set aside for the private use of the British Crown or its representative in Australia. "Domain" has extended its meaning to include estates, and the extent of one's dominion. The idea that landowners can do what they like in their domains dates from medieval concepts of land tenure.



DISTRICT:
"District" was territory under the dominion of a feudal lord. It came from the medieval Latin districtus from the verb distringere, "to seize, compel," source also of "
distrain" and "distress." "District" replaced the Old English ymbhwyrft "circuit."



DOMINION: "Dominion," "desmesne," and "domain" all come via the French from the Latin dominium, "property." In Roman society, the domini were masters and owners, particularly of slaves. In the King James Bible, "Dominion" was used to translate Genesis1:28 where God commanded "man" to exert dominion over the earth. "Dominion" was the term the British Empire applied to its territories across the globe. Australia was a Dominion in 1901. In 1953 the term was replaced by another medieval French word "realm," but "Her Majesty's dominions" is still used in a constitutional context, referring to "all the realms and territories of the Sovereign," says Wikipedia.



EMPIRE:
"Empire" and "emperor" arrived via Old French, from the Latin imperare, to command, says John Ayto. "Invade, search out, capture, vanquish and subdue all Saracens and pagans ... and other enemies of Christ," ordered Pope Nicholas V in 1452. The head of the Roman Church also directed that non-Christians be "reduced to perpetual slavery." This was an ongoing papal policy, for in the 1493 Inter Cetera bull Pope Alexander VI ordered: "Barbarous nations be over thrown."

In the next 500 years, these papal bulls legitimized Europe's global land grab in which
"more than 96 million Indigenous peoples" were "lost," asserted Oglala Lakota Birgil Kills Straight, in1992. Kills Straight contrasted his people's traditional knowledge of "natural laws and Mother Earth as a spiritual entity" with "manmade laws based on capitalistic economies and domination over nature." [Valerie Taliman, "Revoke the Inter Cetera Bull"]

Calls to the Roman Church to revoke the Inter Cetera bull of 1493 as a symbolic "end to this tradition of subjugation" to this date have gone unheeded.



ENVIRONMENT:
"Environ" came via the Old French environer, "to surround protectively or hostilely. "Environment" developed in the 17th century, meaning "state of being environed," notes Douglas Harper. [Online Etymology Dictionary] In the 19th century it became synonymous with nature and neighbourhood and in the 20th century accrued an ecological association.



ESTATE:
Both "estate" and "state" are basically the same word. Both come via the
Old French estat from the Latin status "way of standing, condition," source of the English "status." William the Conqueror paid for his armed forces with confiscated land. So, social standing became aligned with private land ownership: estates.


FARM: "Farm" derives from the Anglo-Norman ferme, the fixed yearly rent due to the lord under Norman occupation.It replaced the Old English eorð-tilð, earth tillage and suppressed the practice of seeking Moðor Eorð, Mother Earth's blessing before tilling the soil.

FENCE: Abbreviation of "defence," from the Old French defens, to ward off. "Fence" replaced the Old English pearroc enclosure or ærhege, hedge of sacred trees.

GOVERN: "Govern" came via the Old French, via Latin, from the Greek kubernan "steer a ship," source of "cybernetics," says John Ayto. In the thirteenth century "govern" meant to "rule with authority," to rule and regulate. It replaced the Old English leodweard guardianship of the people.

MONEY: Coin after the Norman Conquest was known by the Old French name moneie which became the English "money." It's derived from the Latin moneta. Juno Moneta was the Roman Mother Goddess who guarded the Temple & mint, and who bestowed blessings upon coins to be circulated. Juno, source of the English June, derives from an Indo-European word meaning "vital force," and Juno Moneta ensured that this was shared. In contrast, William the Bastard taxed the English to the point of oppression. While the workers became impoverished, the Norman aristocracy squandered the country's money in their fortified castles. Money is a medieval construct which maintains an inequitable distribution of the world's wealth. Ironically, on the Australian $50 note, Ngarrindjeri elder David Unaipon (1872-1967) has the honour of being depicted. Author, orator, preacher, scientist, inventor, Unaipon was a strong advocate for social justice, especially for his people. "Release the bonds," he pleaded.

OCCUPY: "Occupy" comes via Anglo-Norman occupier from the Latin occupare seize forcefully.

PARK: After the Norman Conquest, land which once held in common was enclosed for royal hunting and took the Old French name parc. Putting military vehicles in an enclosed area gave rise to the verb "to park," says John Ayto.

PARLIAMENT: After the Norman Conquest, parlement, from the Old French parler speak, was a conference or a consultative assembly. It soon became "parliament" a legislative body. It replaced the Old English moot which took place at a holy hill or mound, a sacred oak tree, a stone monument, or crossroads. In each borough, the head of each household had the right to appear. William the Conqueror placed the boroughs under the military control of loyal lords, and business was conducted at a centralized weekly indoor assembly, the court of Hustings.

A Parliamentarian was, in the 17th century, the name for "one of the sides of the English Civil War," notes Douglas Harper, and only came to mean a member of Parliament in the 19th century. In South Australia, the Ngarrindjeri had their right to vote taken away with Federation in 1901, not to return again for another 6 decades.

PEACE: "Peace" in 12th century English meant "freedom from civil disorder," says Douglas Harper. [Online Etymology Dictionary] "Civil disorder" is a euphemism for the resistance of the local inhabitants to the Norman Invasion. "Peace" was brought about by a brutal "smash and burn" policy which saw much of the north of English levelled to the ground, its population massacred. "Peace" is derived via the Anglo-Norman pes, from the Latin pax, from pak, source of the English "pact" and "pole." Presumably, when a pact was made between rulers disputing territory, a "pole" was placed in the ground to mark changed boundaries. "Peace" replaced the Old English sibb, related to the English "sibling" and "gossip." In Old English, sibb "peace" wasn't a truce after war, but the result of fostering relationships, alliances and kinship.

PROPERTY: The English word "property" derives from the Old French propriete, from the Latin proprietas, "ownership," notes etymologist John Ayto, [Dictionary of Word Origins, p415] In 1085, William the Bastard, commissioned the Domesday Book in order to know exactly what he possessed and how much taxation he could reap. Land, livestock, crops, people all were considered his property.

PROVINCE:
"Province" derives from the Old French province, from the Latin provincia "region of conquered territory." [Concise Oxford Dictionary of
English Etymology, p375] In 1834, an act of the British Parliament and signed by another King William, authorized the theft of First Nations' Country, declared it "waste and unoccupied," and legitimized the "Colonization" of the "British Province or Provinces" of South Australia.


SOVEREIGN: The sovereign, supreme ruler, comes via Old French, from the Latin super-anus, from the Latin super "above." "Sovereign" replaced the Old English an-wealda. Weald was Old English for "power," as well as "forest" or "wood," source not only of food, but also a sacred place where the power of deity was met. Union with the Goddess, Queen of the Land, gave the elected Old English cyning king the power to rule, but a Norman "sovereign" imposed power from above.


TERRITORY: Coming from the Latin territorium, possibly from terra land or terrere "frighten," says Douglas Harper, "territory" etymologically is land where intruders are warned off. The doctrine of Terra nullius used by European empires to legitimize land thefts, was based on the ancient Roman law that Res nullius: things not owned, which included the property of an enemy, could belong to the first possessor. In the preamble of the 1834 South Australian Foundation Act this territory was described as "waste and unoccupied:" Until the Mabo High Court decision in1992, Australia maintained the lie of Terra nullius.

Ngarrindjeri elder Tom Trevorrow points to tourist information signs in the Coorong National Park which say: "The Coorong was the territory of an Aboriginal group called the Ngarrindjeri." Thus, with the use of the English past tense, Tom and his people are still written out of existence.




TREATY: Treat, the verb and the noun, treatise, treaty and
tractor came into English from the Latin tractere to drag, says Ayto. The Anglo-Norman verb treter in the 13th century meant to deal with, hence "treatment" in a managerial or medical sense. In the 14th century "treaty" became "an action of discussing terms," notes Douglas Harper. "Treatise" replaced the Old English larspell, literally "lore speech," " to treat" replaced lacnian, to heal, while "treaty" replaced settlements under the Anglo-Saxon code of honour. The Anglo-Norman treaty bought off rivals for the Crown, or to avoid more bloodshed was a victor's form of blackmail or revenge over the vanquished. In 1979 a National Aboriginal Conference preferred the term Makarrata to "treaty." Makarrata is a Yolgnu word for the ritual which after a dispute restores good relationships, good feelings, by removing blame or guilt.


DEGRADING ENGLISH: Some Old English words survived the Norman Invasion, but often meanings, especially of words related to land usage, were degraded under the influence of Norman-French:

BRIGHT:Derived from the old English bryght, from the Indo-European *bhereg to shine, says John Ayto, "bright" shares its origins with Brighid, Gaelic Earth goddess. The Shining Ones are the Gaelic Fae spirits of nature. Brighid who also has the title Sireadh Thall "Seek beyond," was Christianized as St Brigit or St Bride. [www.ceilede.uk.co]

EARTH:
Before the Norman Conquest,
the Old English for "country" was
folcland, Land of the people, or Earð, respected Mother Earth. Before turning the soil to plant crops, Old English farmers chanted a sacred invocation: Erce, Erce, Erce, Eorþan Modor Earth, Mother of Earth.
Earð or Eorða derived from the Norse norn Urða who draws water from the Well of Urð to water the Tree of Life. Now "earth" is synonymous with dirt, or an inanimate object revolving around the sun.

GROUND: In old English grund was the "deep," a place of mystery, related to grynde, abyss. Grund was not lifeless, but inhabited by grund-wyrgen, fierce female portents. Grund was the Underworld, or Otherworld, home of spirits, similar to the Gaelic domhain, world, universe, the Earth, from the Old Irish domun, from the Indo-European *dheub-, which gave rise to the English "deep" and "dive." The Irish might say: Ta an domhain saibhris aige, "The world of wealth is at him." It is the domhain Mother Earth who gives the wealth, in contrast to English where wealth is ascribed to a person as status: "She is wealthy."

HOLINESS: Today "holiness" is the province of religion, but in Old English holy ground was a sanctuary protected by sacred trees. In Gaelic law, felling sacred trees was an offence punishable by death. Hail, hale, hallow, heal, health, holy, and whole come from the Germanic khailaz a place of good omen, says Ayto. Holiness is also related to the Old English rune mother hægl, the hail-like cosmic egg of Creation. [RWV Elliott, Runes, p49]



LAND: Today any area of ground is called land, but the word comes from the prehistoric Germanic *landam, a sacred enclosed area, says Ayto. The
ancient sense of the land as sacred and a house of deity is still found in the related Welsh llan church.



LOT: A parcel of land that can be bought and sold was in Old English hlot. A hlot was actually an object which decided a share of land held by the community in common. Some plots of land were more productive than others, and so casting lots handed the decision to the gods.

THING: In Old English a þing "thing," from the verb þingan to invite, was a deed, an event, a cause, a reason or motive, a discussion, a matter of business, assembly, council or court of justice. A þingere was an advocate, a mediator, a priest interceding for the people, a þingestre was a priestess, a female advocate, and þinggemearc was the reckoning of time by events. The Icelandic parliament is known as Althing, points out Ayto. The Norman overthrow of the þing led eventually to the corrupting of a "thing" to an inanimate object. I'd like to think of myself as a "thinger" or "thingster," an advocate for respecting the life in all "things."



WEIRD: Today "weird" may mean strange, odd, eccentric, but its original meaning has been corrupted. In the Old English mind, the Earth was crafted by the sacred intention of the Wyrd, derived from the West Saxon weorþan to become, from an Indo-European base *uert- to turn, to wind, and possibly to will and to speak. From *uert- also came the Norse triple-goddess Urðr, known in Old English as the Wyrd Sisters or Three Wyrds, as well as the Old English deity Eorða, Earth. Today, many tourists to the Coorong drive across dunes and through Ngarrindjeri sites at least 12,000 years old, without a second thought for the mess they leave behind on the earth.

WILDERNESS: Today wilderness means a region unspoilt by humans, a tourist terra nullius treasure, and home of wild creatures. In Old English wilde meant free. The Old English wildēornes was a place where creatures and humans alike were free to roam. Wildēornes was a place where deities dwelt and were revered. From dēor is derived "deer" but in Old English dēor meant animal, says Ayto. Dēor may derive from the Indo-European dheu, shining fire, source of "deity" and "divinity." In 1066 William the Bastard gave a quarter of his conquered land to the Church of Rome. It banned the English from visiting the wilderness places for what it considered Pagan worship. Wilderness then became wild, uninhabited and home to the heathen.

ENGLISH APPROPRIATIONS: Furthermore, when English comes into contact with other people's language, it often appropriates words without regard for cultural contexts. English linguists call them "loan" or "borrowed" words:

EMU was appropriated from the Portuguese ema "cassowary." [Australian Aboriginal Words in English, p51]

GALAH was appropriated from the Yuwaalaraay nation, north New South Wales. Originally gilaa, it has been corrupted to mean a "fool." [[Australian Aboriginal Words in English, p84] The long living, mating-for-life galah is a highly intelligent creature.

KANGAROO was taken from the Guugu Yimidhirr gaŋurru, "a large black or grey kangaroo." Captain Cook in 1770 made lists of words from the Guugu Yimidhirr while making repairs to the ship Endeavour. When asking about the names of several marsupials, ganurru was recorded as "kangaroo," but this was "wrongly taken to be the name for any species of kangaroo or wallaby."[Australian Aboriginal Words in English, p57]


LAW: English appropriated the word from Old Norse lagu, replacing the Old English oe, law, says John Ayto. Lagu is the plural of lag, layer. It is also a rune, points out RWV Elliott, which means "water as a source of fertility." Laguz according to some German writers, says Freya Aswyn, means "love or life." In the Norse tradition, layers of honour flow into the Well of Wyrd, says Swain Wodening Canote. Each new life draws upon the ancestors' layers from the Well. Thus Germanic peoples saw themselves as being created by "the law, their deeds being the law, their customs being the law."

TOTEM was appropriated from the Ojibwa ototeman "belonging to a family or group," says Ayto. Totem was assumed to be an animal or natural object representing the emblem of a clan. In Ngarrindjeri, ngartji is often translated as "totem" but ngartji means so much more: friend, messenger, relative, guardian. George Trevorrow explained to Justice Matthews: "Ngartji to non-Aboriginal people is like a totem which each one of us has and each group belongs to...A ngartji is something more than a close friend. It's more than your best friend. It is something more closely to you." [Diane Bell, Ngarrindjeri Wurruwarrin, p205.] And just as I was writing, this "friend" appeared next to my PC:

GLOBAL ENGLISH: English has become a global language. It is the utilitarian currency of the market place, enabling the conveyance of commodities, property, ideas and services. But when English-speakers try to relate to Land that is neither inanimate nor someone's property, English words fail.

GREGARIOUS FIRST LANGUAGES: In contrast, First Peoples' languages are "gregarious," says French socio-linguist, Louis-Jean Calvet. They foster belonging, they nurture relationships and respect diversity. They cross boundaries into liminality and can accommodate the "inexplicable" and "ineffable." [ L-J Calvet, Language Wars: Language Policies and Globalization, p6]

The British imposed English as the official language across its empire, supposedly to unify; in effect to suppress. Since 1800, the number of First Nations' languages spoken fluently has dropped by 90%. The percentage of First Nations' language-speakers declined from 100% in 1800 to 13% in 1996. Of the 250-700 First Nations' languages spoken by around 700 First Nations pre-British Invasion, now only around 20 are considered "viable." [State of Indigenous Languages in Australia-2001]

The extinction of languages is "part of the larger picture of near-total collapse of the worldwide ecosystem," writes Nettle and Romain. [Vanishing Voices, 2000]



English is everywhere in Australia. Under British occupation, First Peoples' languages were banned in misguided policies of "Assimilation." Australia has been engineered as a mono-lingual society in the erroneous belief that universal English delivers social cohesion. It hasn't worked. The "mono-lingual mind-set" was evident in policies of the Howard Federal Government. Indigenous Affairs Minister ignored a report which found that "students achieve better levels of learning" when " the home languages and cultures of students are reflected in their learning experiences and learning environments." [Indigenous Languages and Cultures in Northern Territory Schools Report 2004-2005] The minister believed that "ensuring" all "Aboriginal children" learnt English would give them " the same opportunities as white children." ["Indigenous school plan criticised," The Sydney Morning Herald, 26 May, 2007.]



In contrast,
the European Union encourages its citizens to be multi-lingual. In Article 22 of its Charter of Fundamental Rights, the EU declares its respect for linguistic diversity, linking it with acceptance of the diversity between peoples, and respect for cultural difference. Article 21 prohibits discrimination on the grounds of language. Languages are in fact "instruments of inclusion," says Clyne.

Australia currently does not meet the aspirations set out in Article 13 of the United Nations 2007 Declaration on the right of Indigenous peoples. It states: "Indigenous peoples have the right to revitalize, use, develop and transmit to future generations their histories, language, oral traditions, philosophies, writing systems and literatures, and to designate and retain their own names for communities, places and persons."



It appears that our local community paper, the Lakelander, does not meet the aspirations of Article 13. The work of Ngarrindjeri artists was featured on the front page of Issues 15 and 20, 2008, but in both instances there was no appropriate acknowledgement of their nation's name, despite a particular request by at least one artist and
despite a local Indigenous population of several hundred. In a previous issue, a report on a significant local concert omitted all mention of the Ngarrindjeri Welcome to Country speech by the Chair of Raukkan Council.



Yet English names dominate the landscape, flora and fauna. The grass-tree that once grew prolifically on the Narrung Peninsula is found on websites with the racist name "black-boy."
"Black boy," was the name given to enslaved First Peoples. Yet today this tragic history is trivialised with "black-boy" being used as the name of an Australian bore, camp, cave, cottage, creek, falls, forest, flower essence, grass-tree, eucalypt, hill, hollow, horse, insect, kennels, money-box, motel, outstation, park, plain, ridge, rose, springs, steamship, trail, walk, way, and winery.



"From the time of European settlement, English has become Australianized in speech communities: the European and the Indigenous communities," writes researcher Ian G Malcolm. Malcolm points out that while linguistically there is little to distinguish the two dialects, speakers of First Nations' English "suffer discrimination when it comes to receiving services intended to be equally available to all Australians."

Significantly, the First Nations' way of being in the world is not relinquished upon learning English.
"Life-space" and "frameworks of activity and relationship" are maintained, observed Malcolm. [Inquiry into the Needs of Metropolitan and Urban Dwelling Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peoples.]



Furthermore, First Nations' writers have "reinvented and redirected the language imposed on them into a powerful tool of resistance and resilience," writes Diane Bell. [Ngarrindjeri Wurruwarrin, p143] The following are English words which,in First Nations' contexts, demonstrate continuity of pre-invasion cultural frameworks.



COUNTRY:
The First Nations' English usage of "Country," has no possessive article, as in "Caring for Country."

"Country in Aboriginal English," says academic Deborah Bird Rose, "is not a common noun, but a proper noun." [Rose, Nourishing Terrains, Australian Aboriginal Views of Landscape and Wilderness.]



In First Nations' English, Country is a "living entity" with a "will towards life," observes Rose. First Peoples relate to Country in a kinship relationship. " People and Country take care of each other," writes Rose. Country was created, is recreated by Ancestral custodians.



Country is a "big book,"
says Ngarrindjeri rupelli, George Trevorrow . "Now, over the years, people been taking ... like tearing pages out of our book ... and that leaves us with a big blank." [Ngarrindjeri Wurruwarrin, p307]



The Ngarrindjeri translate "Country" as Ruwi, but unlike countries of the British Empire whose boundaries shifted with the latest conquest, Ngarrindjeri
Ruwi is sacred and inviolable.



Ruwi cannot be translate simply. Ngarrindjeri Ruwi, points out Bell, is the "living body" of the lands and waters, creatures and peoples. "Ngarrindjeri Ruwar," sings elder Victor Wilson: "one body,all the people." [Ngarrindjeri Wurruwarrin, pp622-3] So when the Ngarrindjeri speak, their language connects them to the living Country who sustains them.


Different attitudes to Country:

LANGUAGE: English is a language full of individual names for things, right down to the smallest molecule and far out into the universe. English separates each thing, so it appears to exist on its own. In 1870, a German zoologist had to invent a word to describe relationships between living creatures and the land: ecology. In contrast, comes the observation of First Nation's linguist, Jeanie Bell: "Our languages are the voice of the Land and we are the carriers of language."



LAW: Unlike English (Norman-Roman) law which is imposed from above and values property, First Nations' Law arises from the Land and values knowledge given by Spiritual Ancestors in the time of Creation.

"We are asking non-Indigenous people to respect our traditions, our rights and our responsibilities according to Ngarrindjeri laws." [Ngarrindjeri Yarluwar-Rwue Plan]



SACRED describes First Peoples' cultural practices, woven into the seasons of the Earth-world and Sky-world. "Sacred" denotes ancient knowledge to be respected and protected.

"What is sacred?" replied Ramindjeri Ngarrindjeri Paul Norvill. "Culture is sacred!"

"We are deeply offended that a Government in this day and age has the audacity to order an inquiry into our secret, sacred, spiritual beliefs." [Statement to the Hindmarsh Island Royal Commission, 1995, signed by the Ngarrindjeri women.



SOVEREIGNTY in First Nation's English usage refers to connection with Country, traditional lands and waters, never sold nor ceded to any foreign power.



SPIRIT: In First Nation's English "spirit" is used as an adjective, as in "Spirit Country," a reminder that the physical realm is not separate from, but is enlivened with Spirit.



THE CONSEQUENCES OF MONO-LINGUAL AUSTRALIA:
84% of Australians at the 2001 census are mono-lingual: they do not speak a language other than English at home, says the Australian Bureau of Statistics. Romain and Nettle's assertion that language diversity is connected with the health of the environment appears true for the Australia. Parts of the continent are so degraded they have been described as "ecological basket cases," "triage" areas, and "sacrifice zones" with an estimated repair bill of $65 billion.
[Background Briefing, 15/9/02, ABC Radio National]

May we re-phrase this English discourse of dominance over the land to one of respect for the Earth and Her peoples. The UK has laws which protect the language rights of Cynmru speakers in Wales and Gaelic speakers in Scotland. May Australia likewise value First Nations' languages and learn how words can connect us with Country and restore Country.



© Vesper Tjukonai, June 2008